Reduce, reuse, recycle, compost = cheaper than incineration

25 January 2018

NB Derbyshire County Council call the incineration plant ‘biomass’, despite the fact it will be burning plastics (see contract page)
26 January 2017 At Derby City’s full council meeting on Jan 26th, during
Councillors questions,the costs of sending the blackbin (residual waste)
for incineration, to the Shanks incineration plant (now Renewi) were revealed. This showed that the recycling collections were approx £36 per bin and the blackbin (residuals) was £112. Bluebin for plastics, card, metals,glass. Brownbin for garden, kitchen waste, foodwaste scraps (STOP PRESS brownbin to be made free again, after a needless cost was imposed on households, but it may be too late, as people have to register online for this free service)
See table below and PWC/Deloitte et al contracts page for how recycling has to be dismantled to ‘feed’ the Renewi incineration contract  



C 6 – EXTRACTS OF PFI BID
Derby City Council and Derbyshire County Council
Expression of Interest to DEFRA
PFI Funding
Residual Waste Treatment Facility March2008

Table 4.2 Evaluation Criteria used in Current Procurement Process

CriteriaWeighting
Price50%
Deliverability15%
Commercial12.5%
Service Quality10%
Working with the Councils5%
Environmental and Social Responsibility 5%
Stakeholder Engagement 2.5%

4.4.5      The evaluation of solutions proposed by participants has concluded the

             following:               

                –  there are substantial deliverability and/or commercial implications

                   associated with options which rely on sending SRF to market, leading

the Councils to conclude that these options are not currently   deliverable within cost and risk parameters which would be acceptable to the Councils;…

      –  options which combine MBT with thermal treatment are not affordable                          

Extracts From page 31 – para 4.4.31

The option with the lowest overall cost is the option involving conclusion of the existing PPP procurement process

Table 4.4 pg 31)

Option  Total Nominal Cost(1/4/10 to 31/3/37)(£K) Net Present ValueOf Cost (1/4/10 to31/3/37) at 1/4/10(£K)
Do nothing 1,029,974453,791
 Conclude existing PPPprocurement  938,722427,348
PFI Reference Project 988,697446,487

revealing that the existing PPP, recycling collections, are cheaper than incineration